Have you ever wondered why people make such a big deal of slate vs non-slate pool tables? Slate tables are the most common form of pool table for those that want to experience the best quality play possible, or so the theory goes. Additionally, slate tables are commonly more expensive than their wooden brethren. So, which one suits your playstyle the best? Is it worth the extra money for a slate table or can you save a few bucks and just go for a lower-quality model without slate? Read below to find out what we think.
SLATE POOL TABLES
The slate pool table surface is made from a polished slate rock mixed with other minerals to give a smooth and leveled surface. The slate tablet has a thickness roughly from one to two inches. Slate pool table surfaces also vary according to the number of slate segments (1 or 3). The slate table with three-segments is often considered to be the preferred option due to extra stability and durability compared to a one-segment table. Three-segment tables can withstand more force without breaking than a single segment table. It is also essential to note that the slate pool table should be tucked in a wooden frame to add resilience to avoid damaging the slate edges.
Pros
• It has a perfectly flat and leveled table surface for maximum ball rolling and perfect shots. Also, it can be balanced to a precision tolerance of 0.0001 inches.
• Due to its resistance to warping, it is more flexible, durable, and adaptable to environments.
• It requires minimal maintenance since the surface is made from slate rock and hardened by quartz mineral.
• It is durable for decades since the slate rock is hard, waterproof, and doesn’t affect extreme temperature and humidity changes.
• It is also easy to clean and with zero maintenance cost, hence no need to worry if water splashes on its surface. Just replace the surface cloth but not the slate.
• It is more reliable for commercial purposes since the slate surface provides a fair gaming experience if it is used for pool league tournaments.
• Table felt or cloth is easier to replace than the cloth on their wooden counterparts.
Cons
• Considerably more expensive due to the slate base
• Heavy and difficult to move
• Expensive to ship
• Assembly requires more in-depth knowledge about pool table setup. It is often recommended to hire trained professionals.
• Because of its weight, it requires a permanent space and positioning to avoid moving around, which might also damage the floor if frequently dragged around.
NON-SLATE POOL TABLE
As the name suggests, this is a pool table surface made from wood, synthetic slates like Slatron. Playing pool on this surface, you will still enjoy the game; however, the level of quality and enjoyment cannot match that of playing on a slate pool table. Non-slate pool tables are often pressed by fiberboard around the board to make it more durable; hence, you will find the different levels of quality with non-slate tables.
Pros
• It is inexpensive since the material for making the underneath surface is made from synthetic and wood products compared to the slate, which is mined and requires an artisan, thus incurring more cost.
• Lightweight and easier to move
• Flexible and easier to assemble/dis-assemble
• Recommended for children and beginners
Cons
• Easier to be damaged by spills due to the wooden layer
• It cannot withstand extreme humidity and temperature, which results in warping; hence, it is good to consider keeping it in a place free from moisture and high temperature (see Should You Put a Pool Table in a Garage).
• The trueness of the surface is not perfectly flat and smooth, thus reducing maximum ball control.
• Non-slate table cloths are not easy to upgrade since most of them do come as a complete unit out of the box.
• It is not durable since the materials for the pool table materials degrade faster. These tables need to be replaced much sooner than a slate model.
• Extra precautions should be taken to extend the longevity of the table.
• It is not recommendable for commercial purposes as it chips and wears off faster, and the gaming quality is low due to the uneven surface.
• As compared to the slate table, the non-slate table cannot be leveled to precision, which increases the probability of the ball rolling in the wrong direction.
Final Thoughts
Slate tables are commonly considered to be the cream of the crop in relation to which one is best. Slate tables last for many years, provide a more stable playing experience, and are the common choice for tournaments. Unfortunately, you can expect to spend more money when purchasing a slate model compared to a non-slate model. Which version works best for you is largely dependent on how you plan on using it. If you want to save a few bucks and still have a great time playing pool in your home, a non-slate model is probably best for you. If, on the other hand, you are looking for tournament-level play and plan on keeping a table for generations, the slate model may be the best choice.
